FAQ  •  Login

Prequels, remakes and sequels...

<<

Leon Corporation

User avatar

Rep Detector Handler
Rep Detector Handler

Posts: 342

Joined: Sat Dec 27, 2003 5:56 pm

Post Mon Sep 06, 2004 6:25 am

Deckard BR26354 wrote:Personally, I don't consider Star Wars as true Sci-Fi ...


In movie guides and books it's definitely called science fiction.
Image
Leon Corporation Employee
<<

Deckard BR26354

User avatar

Veteran Blade Runner
Veteran Blade Runner

Posts: 1202

Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2001 6:00 pm

Location: UK

Post Tue Sep 07, 2004 1:56 am

8)
Richard Gunn

We each live in our own realities - who's maintaining yours?

The only thing that you can be 100% sure of, is that you can't be 100% sure of anything.
<<

zoomer_one

User avatar

Rep Detector
Rep Detector

Posts: 90

Joined: Sat Sep 04, 2004 11:15 pm

Location: Ontario, Canada

Post Tue Sep 07, 2004 8:49 am

Leon Corporation wrote:Maybe. My first reaction would be "yes", but when thinking about what made the previous ones (2001, Star Wars, Alien, Blade Runner and even Gattaca) so special, I'm suddenly not altogether sure if The Matrix fits the bill. The martial arts fighting was so important that it might overshadow other elements in that movie. Could it be that The Matrix is a good action film but nothing more? I wonder...


Well...martial arts aside...you do have to admit that it did (even if it was just after that first movie) manage to get really deep into the whole aspect of "what is real?"

I think the first film could have been made a classic...had they not ruined the whole thing by making sequels. But hey...thats me.

So does that mean The Fifth Element doesn't count as a true sci fi?
<<

Centauro

User avatar

Blade Runner
Blade Runner

Posts: 729

Joined: Thu Jul 05, 2001 6:00 pm

Location: Bogota, DC [CO]

Post Wed Sep 08, 2004 4:38 am

If Space Opera counts as a sub-genre of Sci-Fi (I'm inclined to think it is), then yes the Fifth Element is sci-fi.
-------------------------------------------------------------- Revel In Your Time --------------------------------------------------------------

Image
<<

Deckard BR26354

User avatar

Veteran Blade Runner
Veteran Blade Runner

Posts: 1202

Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2001 6:00 pm

Location: UK

Post Mon Sep 20, 2004 6:31 pm

So does that mean The Fifth Element doesn't count as a true sci fi?


Erm, in my book, no - it's just another action fantasy that happens to be set in the future - it's closer to Lord of the Rings and Star Wars than it is Blade Runner. It meets two of the three attributes that I use to measure a good Sci-Fi story.

The whole point of a Sci-fi story is to explore a current scientific concept or technology and inform the viewer/reader of the possible issues associated with advancing the concept/technology in that direction. Secondary themes might include social, economic and political trends.

In my opinion a true Sci-Fi story must:

1 - explore current "cutting-edge" technology/concepts
2 - explore the effects on our society/civilisation (the human condition)
3 - maintain a plausable version of a possible future or explicitly describe a reasonable alternative historic path for the human race.

The fifth element meets attributes 2 and 3 only. Sure, it shows lots of technology but none of it is crucial to the story - it's all just advanced 'tools' , 'weapons' and 'vehicles'.

Star Wars meets none of the criteria and is therefore not Sci-Fi. The emphasis is purely on the action.
Richard Gunn

We each live in our own realities - who's maintaining yours?

The only thing that you can be 100% sure of, is that you can't be 100% sure of anything.
<<

Leon Corporation

User avatar

Rep Detector Handler
Rep Detector Handler

Posts: 342

Joined: Sat Dec 27, 2003 5:56 pm

Post Tue Sep 21, 2004 2:46 am

The only criterium a SF movie must have is a scene involving the 2nd Street Tunnel.

Image

Yep, only true SF fans know what I'm talking about :wink: .
Image
Leon Corporation Employee
<<

ridleynoir

User avatar

Veteran Blade Runner
Veteran Blade Runner

Posts: 1335

Joined: Wed Mar 13, 2002 6:00 pm

Location: Rochester NY

Post Tue Sep 21, 2004 10:59 am

is this in reference to THX-1138?
Image
<<

Deckard BR26354

User avatar

Veteran Blade Runner
Veteran Blade Runner

Posts: 1202

Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2001 6:00 pm

Location: UK

Post Wed Sep 22, 2004 9:50 am

The only criterium a SF movie must have is a scene involving the 2nd Street Tunnel.


Gattacca featured that tunnel and is also true Sci-Fi...

Can't remember - did I, Robot (also true Sci-Fi) feature this tunnel?
Richard Gunn

We each live in our own realities - who's maintaining yours?

The only thing that you can be 100% sure of, is that you can't be 100% sure of anything.
<<

Leon Corporation

User avatar

Rep Detector Handler
Rep Detector Handler

Posts: 342

Joined: Sat Dec 27, 2003 5:56 pm

Post Thu Sep 23, 2004 2:41 am

Deckard BR26354 wrote:
The only criterium a SF movie must have is a scene involving the 2nd Street Tunnel.


Gattacca featured that tunnel and is also true Sci-Fi...

Can't remember - did I, Robot (also true Sci-Fi) feature this tunnel?


I have not seen I, Robot but lots of other SF movies make use of this tunnel too.

I thought BR fans had an eye for detail? I must've been wrong then :wink: . Maybe you're all in it for the cool action scenes after all :D .
Image
Leon Corporation Employee
<<

Deckard BR26354

User avatar

Veteran Blade Runner
Veteran Blade Runner

Posts: 1202

Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2001 6:00 pm

Location: UK

Post Thu Sep 23, 2004 4:46 am

Leon Corporation wrote:In movie guides and books it's definitely called science fiction.


They obviously don't understand the genre, then.

BTW, I've just been watching the original Star Wars Trilogy on DVD and on at least two occasions (so far) George Lucas quite clearly states that he doesn't consider Star Wars to be Sci-Fi - he uses phrases like "fantasy" and "space opera". So there :P

Oh and The Matrix is definitely Sci-Fi.
Richard Gunn

We each live in our own realities - who's maintaining yours?

The only thing that you can be 100% sure of, is that you can't be 100% sure of anything.
Previous

Return to The Blade Runner Movie Sequel

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests

cron